What about John 3:16?
Fact 1: The love of Christ is not disappointed and His atonement hasn’t in the least failed!
Fact 2: Context matters!
Truth revealed in the Scripture about Christ as Redeemer is the only legitimate and worthy object of faith. And what is that Truth precisely? That Christ made salvation of all men indiscriminately a mere possibility? Is the idea that the atonement was inefficacious for a great many sinners whom apparently it was made for indeed the Truth of Scripture that we call the Good News of the Gospel?